Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Paulo Aguiar's avatar

It’s hard to read through all of that history without seeing the same patterns repeating - just dressed up in modern language and institutions. Empires rebrand themselves and outsource the dirtiest work to whoever is willing to act as the frontline enforcer.

What’s happening in Gaza is simply the continuation of a very old playbook: blockade, starve, crush morale, then pretend it’s all just unfortunate circumstance. The British did it in India and Ireland. The Americans picked it up with Kissinger’s cold-blooded “food-as-power” doctrine. Now Israel carries it forward with Western backing.

The logic is always the same: keep populations weak enough that they can’t resist. It’s not about hatred or ideology as much as it is about raw control over land and resources. That doesn’t make it any less monstrous - it just makes it predictable.

And maybe that’s the point worth holding onto: none of this is accidental, none of it is some freak “tragedy of history.” Once you see that, the pieces click into place, and the question shifts from “How could they let this happen?” to “How long will people keep letting them run the same game?”

It feels grim to admit, but maybe honesty about the nature of power is the first step toward breaking it.

Otherwise, we’ll keep telling ourselves it’s all just bad luck, or the weather, or some unavoidable clash of cultures. And we know it’s not.

Expand full comment
Bard Joseph's avatar

Ireland 1845.

Population reduced by 2 million.

Expand full comment
172 more comments...

No posts